An Oklahoma court
has
granted Google's Motion to Dismiss the case brought against
them by disgruntled owner of SearchKing, Bob Massa.
Last August, Mr Massa's
PR Ad Network allegedly used Google's proprietory PageRank™
system to sell ad space on his network of portals, which led to Google
manually applying a low PageRank™
score to his network of sites. Mr Massa responded
with a lawsuit, claiming his ability to do business had been infringed by
Google's manual adjustment.
Google responded with a
Motion to Dismiss the case,
asserting they were immune from Tort Liability arising from the manual
devaluation, because PageRank™
constitutes protected speech. This week,
the judge agreed with Google, stating:
"The court simply finds
there is no conceivable way to prove that the relative significance assigned
to a given Web site is false," the judge said. "Accordingly, the court
concludes Google's PageRanks are entitled to full constitutional protection."